Fear and Fortitude
The Indian Express Front Page
Every year since 1984, when the date October 31 comes around, I feel I should pen down my thoughts on that fateful day which tested my abilities as a young teacher. And every year, I let it pass as though it never happened to anyone but me. But this year, a former student of mine, Shivaji Dasgupta, wrote a piece in the online magazine at https://www.newsdrum.in/opinion/the-day-nehrus-daughter-died. I wrote back to him telling him about how I felt and he insisted I write. So here it is.
I put it into this blog - Learn Develop Grow - because I think it formed a bit of all three on that fateful day.
Just another Day
Another October day in my sixth year of teaching at St Xavier's began as usual. I am sure through the fuzziness of memories long gone, there must have been the usual classroom tricks and tantrums, the occasional unit test and a few jokes as only schoolboys know how. Towards the afternoon there was this rumour floating around that the Prime Minister had been assassinated. And in next to no time, the school was declared "off" and teachers, students, parents and even a few office bearers started vanishing in fear of impending doom. The phrase on everyone's lips was that there was rioting and they were targetting the Sikh community. I have a vague recollection of shut offices, with no one to reach out to. No mobile phones were in existence then. Students scampered here and there, obviously concerned about how they would get home.
The School Bus, run by Mr Varma, a teacher, was all ready to leave with its load of kids. Parents were offering to drop their neighbours' kids home. There was a lot of chaos and suddenly the enormity of it all dawned on us. We realised we would have a fairly large bunch of frightened kids who would not easily make it home, especially the kids of the Primary department.
Flight
Many teachers and persons in positions of responsibility chose to leave immediately and head home. Three of us, our Headmaster Fr Adrian Wavreil, Elphage Rozario and myself, grabbed blank registers and pens and headed for the Primary section. Once there we were met by the School Captain, Aditya Khaitan - today a captain of industry - and Mrs Cecelia D'Souza, the larger-than-life teacher in the Primary. There were a few other teachers there, all trying to manage the kids who were most happy to have extra time in school.
We started with trying to list all the kids classwise into various registers, while Fr Wavreil and a few teachers opened the school filing cabinets and pulled out phone numbers. Remember there were no computers to ping and no Google .. so we were totally dependent on technology that millenials will not believe were our only data management tools -- registers and ball point pens.
Meanwhile, seeing the kids bursting with energy, Aditya and I took to the field and organised games of various types to distract the kids (and ourselves) from the crushing reality of what was happening.
Fight
It's all a whirl now, and I can't completely recall the sequence of events, but these are some of the things that happened that day:
- Mrs D'Souza rushed home, changed from her sari to a pair of trousers and a top which gave her greater flexibility for the runaround that soon ensued. I think Aditya too, went and put on his sneakers.
- Two ladies from the ITC building opposite the school, Lita Menezes and Reva Puri, arrived on the scene loaded with orange squash and whatever they could find in the way of biscuits. Kids were getting hungry.
- Fr Wavreil brought out his trusty orange Lambretta scooter and took boys home four at a time - I think he did quite a few trips before the mob drained the air from his tyres and he wheeled the scooter back to the school, after dropping off some more kids. Then he prepared to start walking the nearby boys home.
- I was asked to accompany Mr Varma's school bus towards the south with a busload of boys. We had reached somewhere beyond Lower Circular Road when a mob stopped us with a branch of a tree thrown across the road. I recall my instant reaction was to push the two Sikh kids under the seats and stand in the doorway. All they wanted was Sikhs whom they hoped to beat up or worse. After much cajoling, with my heart firmly in my mouth and my pathetic grasp of Bengali, they allowed us to go and drop the kids off. This did not happen again, but on the way back in the empty bus, the driver, helper and I were forced to park the bus across Lansdowne Road, blocking traffic. With no option, I walked back to the school.
- A parent arrived pushing a cart which is normally used for earthen tea cups (bhaars) which he had "bought" from a vendor. He had come walking from Salt Lake about 15 km away. He arrived past 5pm and offered to take some 6-8 kids home with their bags. Must have been some ride. We could only hope for the best.
- One kid went missing that evening - he was listed and no one could find him. Eventually, Fr Wavreil informed us later that a call from his parents past 2 a.m. confirmed that he had walked home to Lake Town (or somewhere equally distant), perhaps 20+ km away.
- It was late evening when Aditya, Elphage and I left. We had accounted for more than 300 children. Elphage had stayed with the registers, organising the pick ups and despatches and helping with the crying kids. We walked back to Ripon Street and Serang Lane respectively, promising to check in the next morning.
Evening Madness
The madness, for me, did not end there.
As I reached home my mother asked me to go to the house of some people from our community. They had called - we fortunately had one of the rare telephones at home - and said they were terrified and that I should come and be with them that night. A mother and her two daughters living alone in a building full of Sikhs! I went. Walking the distance in fear and alert for anything.
When I reached the house, they were so terrified that they wouldn't open the door till I slipped a piece of paper under it with my name. The rest of the night was pure terror as marauding bands of rioters banged on the doors, screamed outside and pulled furniture and fittings from the neighbours houses. This was at the corner of S N Banerjee Road and Wellesley. We watched in horror through window slats as they piled goods onto the road and set them on fire. And regular though intermittent pounding on the front door had us all alert and in total fear. I must admit that I wasn't the seniormost "child" there, being in between the two daughters in age. But I was a man, so that helped.
The next morning, after a delightful breakfast made lovingly by the family, I left to see how my mother was doing. I passed smouldering piles of burnt possessions, and smouldering passions slowly cooling in the baleful glares we were all receiving from each other, over the smell of burnt rubber tyres.
There was an aura of guilt too. The burning and carnage was only part of the story. The looting of Sikh houses was the take-home for the mob. Known to be fairly well off, this unfortunate community lost wealth, possessions and a lot of courage that night. Not to mention lives - maybe less in West Bengal than in the Delhi region, but a few who were known to me.
In silent dignity, showing exemplary fortitude, many of them headed away, back to Punjab. The ubiquitous and ever-polite Sikh taxi driver dwindled to a small minority. They have been replaced by a brand of uncouth cabbie that leaves us cringing and begging on the roadsides. Businesses shut, dhaba fires went cold, houses were sold and many of my friends left this city. The ones that were left behind bounced back slowly but surely - such is the resilience of the community.
So well depicted......Thank God for teachers like you !
ReplyDeleteI remember the house at the corner.....if you remember the house opposite where a young lady sneakily took her Sikh friend out in a dress after having to cut his hair,shave his legs and Ddon some make up.....to escape the frenzied mob.
I don't remember this, but I am sure it happened as you have recorded. There was so much going on that night and the days that followed. Matched only by the aftermath of the demolition of the Babri Masjid .. that's another story.
DeleteSir, this is an exceptional recollection of an episode we must remember forever. A few thoughts come to mind. The courage, selflessness and commitment of teachers like you and Father Wavreil. The scooter story, the nighttime experience and the mob stopping the bus are spinechilling anecdotes. As is the spirit that once defined St.Xavier's the institution and shaped the futures of so many. This must be shared not just as a memory aid but a life lesson. Thank you for writing.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Shivaji, for pushing me to write this. And I have linked your article as well in the hope that people will see your views too.
DeleteLeslie,
ReplyDeleteThis time you evoked that dreadful day. Brought back the amazement I felt when I learned that Calcuttans actually attacked, looted & killed Sikhs!!! Muslims I was used to. But couldn’t believe they’d do this to Sikhs. I was depressed for days afterwards.
Deepa was one of the parents who ran to Short Street, grabbed Dev and hurried home with him. Through you we heard the other side - what happened to the kids that stayed back. And the fear of other people who were caught in the middle.
Heroes are not those who are not afraid. They are those who ARE afraid but do what’s needed to be done anyway. You were a real hero - along with the others who helped the kids.
Thanks for this expression of faith. Much appreciated
DeleteSir, I dont have much recollection of what happened that day. I was in class 2...I know someone came and took me home but I do remember the fear. That fear was strange... it's something I can put into words today, at that tender age I was very confused. It would be interesting to read through anything you write on the babri masjid demolition - that is much clearer - Class X!
ReplyDeleteThanks for this memory. It's one way to learn history..... one of the few subjects you did not teach me in school.
Robert. Beech.
Thanks. But I wouldn't term it history - these are memories that were real and personal but not verifiable by historians.
DeleteI am in a complete time warp. Surprised to know that 38 years ago, Lake town exists.
ReplyDeleteMay not have been Lake Town but the impression was that it was very far and the child reached home around 2 a.m.
DeleteLake Town did exist from long before 1984.
DeleteThough I was a student myself back then I remember horror stories being told and re told and one that I cannot fathom is of this Sikh family from Patna, where they had to sell their house and flee and later came back to live as tenants in that very same place. Can’t imagine what four generations would have gone through.
ReplyDeleteDear Sir,
ReplyDeleteI was fortunate to have been tutored by you (8B) in 1981-82. And thanks to this account, I am still learning from you, Mr. Rozario and (the late) Fr. Wavriel - these lessona are worth learning, more valuable than all those subjects put together in school. I feels great to be able to still sit at the feet of one's teachers and keep learning...
Hi Sir, this is very well written indeed and brought back the memories of that day. I was in Class 4 in the primary school and remember the tensed atmosphere and confusion that was felt all around. We used to live at Wood Street and I was lucky to be home on time. Punishing a community for the actions of one or a few individuals is really incomprehensible. Thank you Sir.
ReplyDelete(Anand Kenkare)